The South PacificBoard

The state of TSP RP is incredibly bad, one liners and constant warring (godmodding in those wars all the time to). Critism of this is not rude but many people just ignore it and continue.

In other words, "Stop complaining about our terrible RP". People can express their opinions even if they aren't five star reviews.

If people make good, non-godmoddy roleplay being less realistic is completely fine! However, when it is just I INVADE HALF YOUR COUNTRY or MY TROOPS BEAT YOURS. It's not any fun or does it give a chance for good rp.

They were providing actual criticism, you called them rude.

Last quote I'm gonna respond to. TSP RP is terrible, godmodding, oneliners and constant war is rampant. You were the one mainly being rude to someone trying to provide criticism because it seems you don't like when people call out the state of RP. Just put effort into posts and don't godmod. I know my rp was quite bad but I've tried to steer clear of how bad it used to be.

Before we look at what Kandorith said, even if you didn't like how they said it, you chose to respond and seem to be shocked they y'know still said they don't like TSP RP. Also, I'm not attacking you or Paganan but simply saying what I think.
Also, you practically told them "IF YOU DON'T THINK IT'S GOOD, DON'T SPEAK". Quite different to "letting people share opinions on how bad it is" but I'll give the benefit of the doubt and I'll just say it's you not liking the way they talked about it.

Let's go and see what they put.
I don't see anything that could be rude here, simply saying how unrealistic the whole thing is. (I changed their name so it doesn't ping them).
Paganan chooses to respond with "no one cares about the wars".
Still not sensing the toxicity, only seems to be somewhat making fun of the state of "rp".
Alright, first of all "coolio" doesn't seem to have bad intentions but could possibly be seen as dismissing it. However, I see both sides of that and I don't think it's a big deal.

Secondly, Paganan did just sorta say "it's just an rp" kind of dismissing the concept of not godmodding but yet again probably not bad intentions. Kandorith was probably a tiny bit rude in the post but it could just be them trying to raise a few points.
You decide to respond, when you didn't have to but I've already covered how it basically reads "don't say bad stuff or criticism, keep it to yourself".Paganan didn't have to be somewhat rude by including "blah,blah,blah" and "PS: I don't read your text". They could of not said anything but still decided to do it.It's an opinion, simple. I don't see anything wrong with it.
I don't think I've ever seen Kandorith say you ruined TSP, you seem to of made that up or I must of missed something. Also, there you go again with don't criticise us.
Sort of like what I said before, it's an opinion and criticism can help someone improve. You don't just silence it because it doesn't give 5 stars to something you like.
At this point, you've seemed to been a bit rude to Kandorith who was just criticising the region not them. You may not like critism but people are allowed to share their opinions anyway.
Not sure about the puppet part but the rest seems to be honestly quite true.
I don't think they were the ones being rude a lot of the time.
They didn't say (to my knowledge) you were ruining TSP! They simply expressed their opinion of TSP rp and the region as a whole, you decided to intervene and respond. You could of ignored it but decided to turn it into a conflict. They may of been rude in a post or two but you seemed to of been rude to someone sharing their opinion.