by Max Barry

Latest Forum Topics

Ad From Max

Providence: The new novel by Max Barry, creator of NationStates

4

DispatchMetaReference

by The Government Department of European WA Office. . 87 reads.

WA Office | International Radio Standards Act

| GOVERNMENT | HOME OFFICE | FOREIGN OFFICE | WA OFFICE | DISPATCHES |
| ABOUT | STAFF | OPINIONS |

There are two opinions on this proposal.

The first is Kenmoria's:

The proposal at-vote, “International Radio Standards Act”, aims to create international legislation to ensure the safety and compatibility of radio transmissions across member states. It does so both by protecting the freedom of member nations to regulate radio devices to ensure that military broadcasts are not received and no damage can be dealt by the radio frequencies themselves, and by allocating bands of the radio spectrum for use by member states.

The first goal, to ensure international radio safety, is accomplished principally by clause 4. Although it is true that clause 4 permits actions which, due to the nature of the World Assembly, would be permitted in the absence of any legislation on the matter, it is also true that this proposal thereby prevents future legislation from restricting member states from employing policies to ensure the safety of radio in their territories. Clause 4 explicitly protects the rights of member nations to disallow their citizens access to military transmissions, for example.

The second aim of the proposal, compatibility between states, is accomplished in clause 2. By allocating specific bands of the radio spectrum for national usage, the IRA ensures that there is not a risk of interference between states, which could cause loss of audio quality to an unintelligible extent, if other factors that lower radio quality are also present.

To conclude, the “International Radio Standards Act” is a proposal which aims to protect the safety and international compatibility of radio transmissions. It does so in a reasonable manner, leaving open room for member states to make decisions according to local differences, while still tackling the issue with an international focus. Hence, this office recommends a vote FOR the proposal.

The second is Regnum Italiae's:

The proposal at-vote, “International Radio Standards Act”, aims to create international legislation to ensure the safety and compatibility of radio transmissions across member states. While the proposal appears to be well written, there are a few issues that rise our concerns about its effectiveness.

Firstly, while the preamble clearly states "Considering the detrimental effects that a lack of standards has [...] such as incompatibilities in equipment", the proposal does nothing in this regard and the only provision about radio equipment (section 4) just allows member states to restrict or prohibit some uses, manufacturings, and sales of such equipment.

Secondly, the International Radio Authority established under section 1 has no clear responsibilities or duties, except for the ones defined in sections 2 and 3, namely managing the allocations of frequency slots and keeping a registry of radio transmitters. The IRA is not empowered in any way, for example, of overseeing the management of the mentioned registry, since this is brought upon member states. One might wonders whether such little capabilities are enough to accomplish its purpose and to justify its existence.

Thirdly, the above-mentioned allocation of frequencies is made without any regard to the market regime of the member states and of the technological level of their equipment, thus leading to possibly harmful situations like the de facto nationalizations of frequencies allocations in nations under a free market regime or the impositions of unconvenient allocations to technologically disadvantaged nations.

Finally, we might consider again the rather vague use of the term reasonable that we see throughout the resolution, most notably in section 4(b). The use of this inherently relative term, in fact, makes much more difficult to determine whether nations are making their best effort or not.

For these reasons, we think that the proposal does not fulfill its aims and might even cause harm to some member nations. Thus, we recommend a vote AGAINST the proposal.

Primary author(s): Kenmoria, Regnum Italiae.

Tags

Abercych Acaduil Adamites Afandar Aguera Ahma Alba-nord Albathla Alinions Alqaetia Altanys Alternan Aluziane Alympian Kingdom Ambung Amicities Ancient isles Andorra-taured Andrewea Anglealnd Anglosoai Ansington Anskerdank Anstorias Antwerpen apart Apabeossie Apollonivm Appathian Aragonja Arax Arguistan Aristeme Armbruster Arorska Artacressa Artonin Askandia Athbheochan na tuatha Atheara Athens but better Ausvelt Autofeld Azitupia Azraerie Bareu Bathera Bavira Baxonia Baycanistan Belguim empire Belmoren Betasia Birdopiane Bjergmenstein Bohomo Boldia Bombastion Brakanistan Bread and butter and jam British Alban Burgene Burtosa Byzantinumus Callidoria Caoripp Carphelia Castelblancia Cherised lands of galicia Chioganah Chronus Cocreddia Cogneria Colony of miechow Continental social democrats Courathar Cre Alworkez Crestphalia Cyrothica Cytadela Czarigrad Daarwyrth Dalmannia Daneforth Dannach Dark Matter Dasche Delphinia Demon666 Desibia Destyntine Diets Dipretorian Distelmsland Dog food jungle Domton Don martinoque Dorsendo Drew Durrnil Dreysia Druznia Dukradi Duomenbutle Durlia Durtoria Enotria East carmania East zaolzie Eastern greenlands Eesenland Egyptian mamluk sultanate Eiffelland Einswenn Eldorado2 Elementoria Elisabethshagen Engales and southern ireland Engelhardenia England brotherhood Enway Equatorial zone Eritei Escalver Escann Escavilla Estellan Estonesia Estoniia Esvonia Evergreen keys Fasumia Feria-Alkaline Flippydippy123 Franco-Belguim Free karabakh Free workers macedon Freslond Friimark Gaelia GanymedEuropa Generalitat catalunya Gerarvania German bismarck republic Germania grosspreussen Germany third reich Gizan empire Godefargen Grahamsylnania Great winminster Greater Albaina Greater Bahland Greater british imperial empire Greater deutsch europaische reich Greater Orcadia Greater state of bonnie Greater Tomland Grodisze Hydra-russian empire Hafrsa Heinsbergen Herkori Hertogenbosch Hilbert dimension Hirota Hispania reich Homoople Hunas Hverland Hydrian Ib kingdom Illyrianalbania Imperium Anglorum Imperium germaniae Imperium latine Indalancia Invernessia Irminsulia Jamesreich Javya Jebeland Jethe Jim the Baptist Joklaa Joselix Kabzeel Kaiserreich of the holy roman empire Kalifer and Baska Kamovia Kanokla Kardjali Kenmoria wa mission Keravonia Kingdom of ben at the norrisland Kingdom of bretonia Krystovia Kuhwinkel Kurfuerstentum Brandenburg-Mecklenburg La Gaulle Lagora Landiania Landonastan Lechita empire Leiningerland Leszno Letzte kompanie Lexembourg Liberal federal republic germany Liberny Lieges Lindenhelm Linkisheer Llamas peanuts Lodhs beard Lohika Lovisa Lundelbell Lyallpur Maanenland Madatackaordia Magnus picture Malanisia Mantcor Maraleeri Martelon Masmany Mediama Mer vulek Meropis Migurson Mons graupius Montagne riche Monte Naranja Montegrovia Moravian-Silesian Kingdom Nacionalsocialistas NEW UDS Nanew Nardin Nation of warfare Nea Europa Nedeslavia Neo sindria Neo-notre patrie Neu helvetia und elba Neudeutsches Imperium Nevelja New Astrail New pannonia New Petra New touraine New Vorarlberg New Ylicia Nidowe Nieuw Gent Norbarch Norskheim North Batica North of Americas NorthPortugal Northeast Vatican Notweirdos Nova Prussia Novabritannia Novoavania Nuclear lammi Num ast Nuweland Nyrstaland Ocefate Odwyerica Oena and sandy island Old World Order Orinkwaka Orob Ostermarch Ostrogotharum praeeminebat Othenhiem Outer Sparta Parliamentary Laramidia Pazano Pet rock empire Pierce landicus Pilipinas and Malaya Pollend Popaholick Proutosaure Prussian-union Purgatio Quentenia Regnum Italiae Republic of momolend Republic of ourense Republicofblanc Rhinowolf Rhomi Riega Rijland Romana imperium de italia Rotenstein Roth parel Rouvenor Rowandaa Skully wully Sagral Saint pallas Sakuraka San guglielmo Sancheir Sandie stationd Savinecross Savoy and Milan Scravovia Seims Semult Serbia-macebonia Seristria Shagolaa Shamblia Sicilian imperial-capitalist empire Sienkahn Sinclairtown Skjern Slappee Slavorussia Sloburg Slovanov Slovenian styria Snowfeld Socialist balkans Socialist Soviet Armenia Solteur Someseni South douninitia South St Maarten Squidroidia St jean cap ferrat St Scarlett State of kian Stettland Stromia Stukilo Stumphosse Res Sukitopia Supcotia Swissmas Taboritia Taltenia Tarsena Tenian Terdiatlans Termasek Terranevo The 4th french empire The british royalist union The Champions League The empire of occitania The fair republic The great new swiss The Greater Eastern Republic The haven of corporations The Hazar Amisnery The Kingdom of Denmark The lemanberg The mongol plain The monkey sanctuary The New Dawn Imperium The New Nordic Union The noot nation The oriental empire The peoples republic of new texas The Poland-Lithuania Commonwealth The Pontic State The provisional authority The Reunited Yugoslavs The Scandinavian Realm The scheldt The Seven Provinces The States of Texas and Arkansas The Templar Papal New State The twelve nations of eastern europe The union of scandinavia The Union of the German State The workers unions The wretched of this earth The-British-Isles Thils Tisa confederation Toaddia Toussainti Trixeland Tryienne Twin kingship Ussep Ukraba Uldar Union Umeria United arcadius United empire of arevaan United sornchai Urbintin Vaestsverige Valskraa Vamberry Vartonia Velosia Vieternozsk Viktorias Villaing Visaland Viscland Volara Volonism Walfo Weast sealand Weeddialvon Welsh lands Weltbeherrschung West Geneva Western Berlin Wiener-Neustadt Wombelland Wunly andencria Yahlia Yoannes Zaporizhzhia Zeta and scutari

Why was I tagged?!

Current policy emerged from the poll conducted here, which showed a majority supporting telegrams disseminating these messages to all residents. Internally, however, the Office compromised between telegrams – which many in the region might find spammy, due to the default limitations of telegram mailboxes – and oft-ignored RMB messages.

The above tags were generated automatically by InfoEurope.

You can opt out of tagging by sending a telegram to the Office's WA Secretary or the Undersecretary for Communications. Current staffing information is located in the "STAFF" tab at the top of this page.


RawReport