by Max Barry

Latest Forum Topics

Advertisement

2

DispatchMetaReference

by The Government Department of European WA Office. . 85 reads.

WA Office | Repeal 'Ban on Sterilisation of Minors etc'

| GOVERNMENT | HOME OFFICE | FOREIGN OFFICE | WA OFFICE | DISPATCHES |
| ABOUT | STAFF | OPINIONS |

Writing as the author of GA 472 'Ban on Sterilisation of Minors etc' and GA 486 'Prevention of Forced Sterilisation', I think that GA 472 is deprecated and ought to be repealed. This is not the argument in the proposed repeal.

The first argument given in the proposed repeal is that the structure of Institutional Review Boards in GA 111 'Medical Research Ethics Act' is insufficient because IRBs 'are not required to be staffed with medical experts'. This is untrue. GA 111 defines an 'Institutional Review Board (IRB) as a board of individuals qualified to impartially analyse medical research proposals'. If such boards did not have medical experts, they would be unqualified to analyse such proposals.

The author also argues that requiring permission would create delays. The need for pre-clearance is necessary: sterilisation procedures are mostly non-reversible. It would be folly to allow them without substantial oversight. This principle has been affirmed by the World Assembly not once in GA 472 (the target), but also GA 486.

The third argument is the non-delegation doctrine: that the GA 'should not pass legislation that empowers committees to create secondary legislation'. This argument is bunk. Carrying the argument into fruition, it implies that the Assembly cannot have committees create regulations on pollution, financial products, carbon emissions, etc without either doing it by itself an impossible task when the world is complex or delegating this authority to member nations which the GA cannot trust to carry out its mandate.

Repeal, by itself, of GA 472 would do little harm to the current regulatory regime for the sterilisation minors. But repeal for these reasons undermines the regulatory regime in resolutions using the same language as GA 472, it undermines the Assembly's ability to regulate complex activities, and misleads the public as to how GA 111 operates.

The WA Office recommends voting AGAINST Repeal 'Ban on Sterilisation of Minors etc'.

Primary author(s): Imperium Anglorum.

Tags

6e republique francaise Acaduil Ahma Alba-nord Albathla Alonard Altanys Aluziane Alympian Kingdom Amicities Anatoshia Anglealnd Angleterres Ansington Anskerdank Apabeossie Apollonivm Appathian Aragonja Arax Arguistan Aristeme Arkeyevich Arorska Artonin Aslicuria Ausvelt Bahnhofstrasse Bareu Bathera Bavira Baycanistan Belgique et france Belmoren Betasia Bialopolska Birdopiane Blechingia Blood and destiny Bohomo Boldia Bombastion Brakanistan Bread and butter and jam British Alban British cantha British swahili Bruh momentians Burgene Byzantinumus Cmcii Cadersy Callidoria Capitalist states of usa Carphelia Castelblancia Cherised lands of galicia Chioganah Chronus Cisplatinaa Citrus fruits Continental social democrats Corum55 Cosadamia Cre Alworkez Cydfuddiannaeth Cytadela Czarigrad Dalmannia Daneforth Dannach Dark Matter Dasche Delphinia Deltia- Demon666 Desibia Destyntine Devlina Diets Dipretorian Distelmsland Djennis Dogemark Domton Dorpz Dorsten Drew Durrnil Dreysia Druznia Dukradi Duomenbutle Durlia Durtoria Enotria East zaolzie Eastern greenlands Eesenland Egyptian mamluk sultanate Eiffelland Einswenn El musafir Elisabethshagen Elitestland Emirates of south carolina Encaenia Engales and southern ireland Engelhardenia Eritei Escann Escavilla Essedario Estonesia Esvonia Euristone Euro liberland Evergreen keys Evka Farrensk Fasumia Feria-Alkaline Finish republic Flight force one Franco-Belguim Fredomisa Free karabakh Free workers macedon Frialla Gaiandmo Galrica GanymedEuropa Garandua Garya Generalitat catalunya German bismarck republic German danzig Germania grosspreussen Germany third reich Godefargen Gohia Grand trestan Great robertia Greate san marino Greater Albaina Greater kekkoslovakia Greater Orcadia Greater state of bonnie Greater Tomland Grodisze Gultravia Hydra-russian empire Hafrsa Heinsbergen Herkori Hesperisia Hilbert dimension Hinduistischland Hirota Hispania reich Holy northern greenland Iggly iggle Illyrianalbania Imperium Anglorum Imperium germaniae Imperium Malignis Impollionis Invernessia Irminsulia Isonia 69 Italic league Izpirituen Jambon Jebeland Jim the Baptist Joselix Judeomarksistowskie podlasie Kabzeel Kalifer and Baska Kamovia Kanokla Kardjali Kashtyria Kenmoria wa mission Keravonia Kingdom of ben at the norrisland Kossacks Kuhwinkel Kurfuerstentum Brandenburg-Mecklenburg Kurman Lagenhagen Laggos Lagora Landiania Langan Lavabobia Leille Leiningerland Leszno Letzerlands Lexembourg Leymen Liberal federal republic germany Liberny Lieges Limerickshire Lindenhelm Lithuania and ruthenia Lodhs beard Lohika Lovisa Lucritz Lumitauka Lundelbell Lunisia Lyallpur Lyndismess Maanenland Martelon Mediama Miechow 2 Mielcarek Migurson Milfgaerd Milovia Montagne riche Monte Naranja Monte nigro Moravian-Silesian Kingdom Morotsa NEW UDS Nanew Nardin Nation of warfare Nea Europa Nedeslavia Neudeutsches Imperium Nevelja New Astrail New hevania New leeds state New pannonia New Petra New touraine New Vorarlberg New Ylicia Nieuw Gent Norbarch North Batica North of Americas Northeast Vatican Northern heltan parimenrharky Nova cuscatlan Nova Prussia Novabritannia Novo Portugal Novo provinia Novolemania Nuclear lammi Num ast Nuweland Nyrstaland Old World Order Orinkwaka Orob Ostermarch Oswesch Othenhiem Outer Sparta Parliamentary Laramidia Pazano Permorania Phillicans Pierce landicus Pilipinas and Malaya Pinenses Poland-kaliningrad Pollend Popaholick Premier league Preuen Pribyslavvitz Proutosaure Prussian-union Prusso-britannia Purgatio Pydrus Quentenia Regnum Italiae Reignment Republic of Satherland Republicofblanc Rhinowolf Rhomi Riega Rijland Romainnapo Romana imperium de italia Rotenstein Rouvenor Rowandaa Sablya Sagral Saint enchunsistan San juan bautista i Savinecross Savoy and Milan Scravovia Serbia-macebonia Seristria Shagolaa Shamblia Sicilian imperial-capitalist empire Sinclairtown Sirer Skjern Slavorussia Sloburg Slovanov Slovenian styria Socialist balkans Socialist Soviet Armenia Solteur Someseni South St Maarten Spudguy Squidroidia St Scarlett State of kian Stromia Stukilo Stumphosse Res Suissen Sukitopia Supcotia Switzerland and vorarlberg Taboritia Tarsena Terdiatlans The 4th french empire The Champions League The east atlantic coalition The empire of occitania The Euro Zone The fair republic The great owen The Greater Eastern Republic The ivory tower of academia The Kingdom of Denmark The mongol plain The monkey sanctuary The New Dawn Imperium The new faroe islands The new greater swissland The New Nordic Union The olish union The oriental empire The pagan moon The peoples republic of suffolk The Poland-Lithuania Commonwealth The respectable society The Reunited Yugoslavs The Scandinavian Realm The scheldt The sect meces The Seven Provinces The wretched of this earth The-British-Isles TheDawnNation Thepolis Theodiscland Thesnor Thils Toaddia Toussainti Transmontagne Treehound Trixeland Tryienne Tsar of bulgaria Ukraba Uldar Union Umeria Union of sovereign states and republics United empire of arevaan Uranus2 Urbintin Valskraa Vartonia Velosia Viktorias Vilardosia Visaland Viscland Volara Volonism Vulpan Walfo Warburg Weeddialvon Weird 9265 Welsh lands Weltbeherrschung West Geneva Western Berlin Wiener-Neustadt Wombelland Wunly andencria Yolomimia Yahlia Yoannes Zaporizhzhia Zarulia Zergezovia Zeronica

Why was I tagged?!

Current policy emerged from the poll conducted here, which showed a majority supporting telegrams disseminating these messages to all residents. Internally, however, the Office compromised between telegrams which many in the region might find spammy, due to the default limitations of telegram mailboxes and oft-ignored RMB messages.

The above tags were generated automatically by InfoEurope.

You can opt out of tagging by sending a telegram to the Office's WA Secretary or the Undersecretary for Communications. Current staffing information is located in the "STAFF" tab at the top of this page.



RawReport