by Max Barry

Latest Forum Topics

Advertisement

3

DispatchMetaReference

by The Government Department of European WA Office. . 126 reads.

WA Office | GMO International Trade Accord

| GOVERNMENT | HOME OFFICE | FOREIGN OFFICE | WA OFFICE | DISPATCHES |
| ABOUT | STAFF | OPINIONS |

GMO International Trade Accord aims to encourage the development of biotechnology while also regulating the international trade of genetically modified organisms. The proposal per se is not badly-written, but we want to highlight some flaws that will undermine its effectiveness.

First, the definitions in section 1 exclude genetic modifications obtained through natural means, which could have similarly negative effects on the environment. Gene transfers of this sort would be dangerous regardless of the transfer mechanism.

Second, the legislation uses a committee throughout to establish guidelines and employs the word “reasonable” frequently. Committees in the World Assembly can be helpful legislative tools, but they also necessarily make it difficult to establish a proposal’s precise effect. The specific trade guidelines the committee is tasked to produce in section 2 are entirely unknowable. Nor are the guidelines explicitly enforced on member nations. It is also a mystery as to what the “reasonable” measures in section 3 are.

Normally, “reasonable” is a legal fiction used to describe what precautions the average person would do in negligence cases. It is one thing to say that actions already taken were reasonable. But it is a very different thing to impute a duty to do specific unknown actions from that same fiction.

Third, while the proposal regulates the use of GMOs, it does not similarly limit intellectual property. Naturally-spread genetic material discussed in the first clause, if treated as property under international law, would give rights over large parts of the environment to the intellectual property owners.

Overall, it is our opinion that the proposal at vote is not clear as to what policies are to be implemented. Moreover, the resolution’s scope is large enough to make it difficult for a future patching resolution to identify enough problems to justify its passage. Therefore, we recommend a vote against the resolution.

Primary author(s): Regnum Italiae, Kenmoria, Imperium Anglorum.

Tags

6e republique francaise A state of trance Acaduil Ahma Ahrek Ainee Alba-nord Albathla Alienage Alonard Altanys Aluziane Alympian Kingdom Amalgamated northern europe Amicities Anatoshia Andyvania Angelhelm Anglealnd Ansington Anskerdank Anth citty Apabeossie Apollonivm Appathian Arabia deserta Aragonja Arax Arguistan Aristeme Arorska Aslicuria Atenburgh Ausvelt Bahnhofstrasse Baldrum Bananyas Bareu Bathera Bavira Baycanistan Beans archipelago Beauprix Belakrane Belgique et france Belmoren Betasia Bialopolska Birdopiane Blechingia Blood and destiny Bluche Bohomo Boldia Bounapartia Brakanistan Bread and butter and jam Britannny British Alban Burgene Byzantinumus Cadersy Candavia Capitun Carphelia Cassaracen Central unification Cherised lands of galicia Chioganah Chronus Cockcephia Colorado country Confederation of westphalia Continantia Continental social democrats Corthaen Corum55 Cosadamia Coshia Cottag Cre Alworkez Cydfuddiannaeth Cyprus-greece Cytadela Dalmannia Daneforth Dark Matter Delphinia Destyntine Diets Djennis Dogemark Dombrovia Domton Dorpz Drew Durrnil Druznia Dukradi Duomenbutle Durlia Dutchlandas Dylanese republic Enotria East-thomasland Eastern greenlands Edelsia Eesenland Egyptian mamluk sultanate Eiffelland Einswenn Elisabethshagen Elitestland Emeraldeia Encaenia Engales and southern ireland Engelhardenia Enway Eritei Escann Escavilla Estonesia Esvonia Euro liberland Evergreen keys Evka Fabolionistan Farrensk Fasumia Feria-Alkaline Francette Franco-Belguim Free karabakh Free workers macedon Frialla GanymedEuropa Garya Generalitat catalunya German bismarck republic German danzig Germany third reich Godefargen Gohia Grand palia Grand trestan Great robertia Great winminster Greate san marino Greater belgium Greater kekkoslovakia Greater Orcadia Greater state of bonnie Greater Tomland Gultravia Hydra-russian empire Habsberg Heinsbergen Herkori Hesperisia Hilbert dimension Hirota Hispania reich Holy northern greenland Iggly iggle Illyrianalbania Imperium Anglorum Imperium Malignis Impollionis Indoctia Invernessia Inverstrass Irminsulia Jambon Jarmia Jebeland Jim the Baptist Jordariki Joselix Judeomarksistowskie podlasie Juties Kabzeel Kalifer and Baska Kanokla Kaosukasas Kelkn Kenmoria wa mission Keravonia Khaepitalischt Kiestia Kurman Laggos Leavell Leszno Lexembourg Leymen Liberal federal republic germany Lieges Lindenhelm Linkisheer Lovisa Lucritz Lumitauka Lunisia Lyallpur Mfg r Maanenland Marialeonis Mediama Meryan Metallica state Mezzegra Miechow 2 Mielcarek Migurson Miharr Milfgaerd Montagne riche Monte Naranja Montevino Moravian-Silesian Kingdom Msaladofinger Nanew Nardin Nation of warfare Nea Europa Nedeslavia Neo Splatoonia Neudeutsches Imperium Nevelja New engonia New pannonia New Petra New rickiland New touraine New Ylicia Nidowe Nieuw Gent Nookville Norbarch North Batica North of Americas Northeast Vatican Nouros Nova hollandia Nova Prussia Novabritannia Novo Portugal Novo provinia Novolemania Num ast Nuweland Nyrstaland Of herbshire Old World Order Orinkwaka Orob Ostermarch Oswesch Othenhiem Outer Sparta Pamia Parliamentary Laramidia Pazano Permorania Phillicans Pierce landicus Pilipinas and Malaya Poland-kaliningrad Pollend Pollica Pontus euxinus Pontus and trebizond Popaholick Portlandias Premier league Pribyslavvitz Proutosaure Prussian-union Prusso-britannia Puhja Purgatio Pydrus Quentenia Regnum Italiae Reignment Republic of algarve Republic of Satherland Republicofblanc Rhinowolf Rhomi Riccardo romano Riega Rijland Riverpost Romainnapo Rotenstein Rouvenor Rowandaa Sablya Sagral Savinecross Scravovia Sednan Serbia-macebonia Seristria Shagolaa Shaor Sicilian imperial-capitalist empire Sienkahn Silverwater Sinclairtown Slavorussia Sloburg Slovanov Slovenian styria Socialist balkans Socialist Soviet Armenia Solteur Someseni South St Maarten Soviet italiano Spudguy Squidroidia Srbya St Scarlett State of kian Stromia Stukilo Stumphosse Res Suissen Sunricea Supcotia Swillinia Switiod The 4th french empire The Champions League The empire of occitania The Euro Zone The fair republic The great owen The Greater Eastern Republic The ivory tower of academia The Kingdom of Denmark The mongol plain The monkey sanctuary The New Dawn Imperium The new faroe islands The New Nordic Union The new swissland The pagan moon The peoples republic of suffolk The Poland-Lithuania Commonwealth The Scandinavian Realm The sect meces The Seven Provinces The thirty two counties The wretched of this earth The-British-Isles Thesnor Thils Tiberiopolis Toaddia Toposi Toussainti Transmontagne Treehound Trixeland Trollheimgard Tryienne Tsar of bulgaria Ukraba Umeria Union of sovereign states and republics United empire of arevaan United polarity Uraltia Uranus2 Urbintin Uttterback Valskraa Velosia Viciebskaja Viscland Volara Volonism Vulpan Walfo Warburg Way havion Weeddialvon Welsh lands Weltbeherrschung Wesseals West Geneva Western Berlin Wiener-Neustadt Witenlandia Wombelland Wunly andencria Yolomimia Yahlia Yakon suptica Yoannes Zaporizhzhia Zeronica Zuergendes

Why was I tagged?!

Current policy emerged from the poll conducted here, which showed a majority supporting telegrams disseminating these messages to all residents. Internally, however, the Office compromised between telegrams – which many in the region might find spammy, due to the default limitations of telegram mailboxes – and oft-ignored RMB messages.

The above tags were generated automatically by InfoEurope.

You can opt out of tagging by sending a telegram to the Office's WA Secretary or the Undersecretary for Communications. Current staffing information is located in the "STAFF" tab at the top of this page.



RawReport